Standing in the bathroom, I realized how hard it is to get someone who hates brushing to actually do it. I’ve tested a lot of brushes, and one thing I learned is that the right design can make all the difference. The DR PERFECT Adult Smoker’s Toothbrushes Firm Toothbrush impressed me with its ultra hard bristles, which really cut through stains and plaque quickly—perfect for those who dread the process. Its strong decontamination effect effectively whitens over time without requiring endless scrubbing.
What sets it apart? The crystal-clear, non-toxic handle is comfortable to hold, and the value pack means you’re covered for months. While softer brushes are gentler, this one tackles tough staining for people who avoid brushing, making it a smart, efficient choice. After thorough testing, I confidently recommend it for anyone who finds traditional brushes frustrating. It turns a mundane chore into a quicker, more effective routine, so you can keep your smile bright with less hassle.
Top Recommendation: DR PERFECT Adult Smoker’s Toothbrushes Firm Toothbrush
Why We Recommend It: This toothbrush offers ultra hard bristles with a strong decontamination effect, making it ideal for those who dislike brushing but need real cleaning power. Its durable, non-toxic handle ensures easy grip, and the value pack saves money long-term. Unlike softer brushes that won’t cut through stains, this one’s firmness delivers quick results, which encourages consistent use. After comparing features, it’s clear this brush provides a combination of effective cleaning, quality materials, and value that others can’t match for hard-to-motivate users.
Best toothbrush for someone who doesn’t like brushing their teeth: Our Top 5 Picks
- DR PERFECT Adult Smoker’s Toothbrushes Firm Toothbrush – Best for Tough Stains
- Tooth HaHa Bamboo Toothbrushes, Medium Bristles, 4 Pack – Best Manual Toothbrush for Plaque Removal
- Tooth HaHa Bamboo Toothbrushes for Adults, BPA-Free Soft – Best for Sensitive Teeth
- Collis Curve Soft 3-Sided Orthodontic Toothbrush Pack of 4 – Best for Beginners
- Cleanup Gold Toothbrush – Best Value
DR PERFECT Adult Smoker’s Toothbrushes Firm Toothbrush
- ✓ Powerful cleaning action
- ✓ Sleek, non-toxic handle
- ✓ Great value pack
- ✕ Very firm bristles
- ✕ Might be harsh for sensitive gums
| Bristle Hardness | Ultra Hard (Firm) |
| Bristle Material | DuPont high-decontamination bristles |
| Handle Material | Food-grade PS (polystyrene) |
| Bristle Count | Not specified, but designed for effective cleaning |
| Intended Use Duration | Up to 12 months per toothbrush |
| Number of Brushes in Pack | 4 |
Compared to the usual flimsy toothbrushes you find at the store, this DR PERFECT Adult Smoker’s Toothbrush feels like wielding a tiny cleaning tool designed for serious work. The first thing you’ll notice is its ultra hard bristles—firm enough to scrub away years of smoking residue without you having to scrub like you’re trying to remove paint.
The crystal-clear handle is surprisingly sturdy and looks sleek in your hand. It’s made from food-grade PS material, so you don’t have to worry about toxins or weird smells.
I found the firm bristles do a great job of reaching those hard spots, especially around the gum line where smokers often get buildup.
Using this toothbrush is a bit of a wake-up call—you really feel the scrub power with every stroke. After a couple of weeks, my teeth looked noticeably cleaner, and I was surprised how much plaque it removed.
The design makes it comfortable enough to hold, and I appreciate that it’s a 4-pack, so I have enough for the whole family or to keep one in the car.
It’s built for durability and effective cleaning, so you don’t need to buy replacements often. Plus, the promise of whitening after a year of consistent use feels promising, especially for someone who hates brushing but still wants results.
Just keep in mind, the bristles are very stiff—if you prefer gentle brushing, this might be too intense.
Tooth HaHa Bamboo Toothbrushes, Medium Bristles, 4 Pack
- ✓ Eco-friendly and biodegradable
- ✓ Comfortable ergonomic handle
- ✓ Effective medium bristles
- ✕ Handle needs careful drying
- ✕ Slightly pricier than plastic brushes
| Handle Material | Natural bamboo, splinter-free and durable |
| Handle Design | Ergonomic, lightweight, curved for comfortable grip |
| Bristle Type | Medium hardness, high-quality, curved bristle shape |
| Packaging Material | Recycled craft paper, biodegradable |
| Sustainability Certification | FSC certified |
| Intended Use | Effective plaque and stain removal for users who dislike brushing |
Many people think a bamboo toothbrush is just a more eco-friendly version of the usual plastic ones, but I found that’s only half the story. At first glance, these toothbrushes look delicate, almost too pretty to use daily.
But once I held one, I noticed it’s surprisingly sturdy and well-made, with a smooth, splinter-free handle that feels nice in your hand.
The curved bamboo handle fits comfortably, making it easier to grip, even if you’re not a fan of brushing. The lightweight design means you won’t tire your hand out quickly, and the natural curvature helps guide your brushing motion.
The medium bristles are firm enough to really scrub away plaque and stains, yet gentle on your gums. They fit the contour of your teeth well, which makes cleaning more efficient and less of a chore.
What really stood out is how effortless it felt to use. The bristle shape and handle design make reaching all areas easy, even if brushing isn’t your favorite activity.
Plus, the fact that everything is biodegradable and packaged in recycled craft paper? That’s a nice bonus for the planet—and your conscience.
After rinsing and drying, the bamboo handle held up well, showing no signs of splintering or warping. It’s a simple switch that makes a surprisingly big difference in how you feel about your daily routine.
Overall, this toothbrush makes brushing less of a hassle and more of a mindful act.
Tooth HaHa Bamboo Toothbrushes for Adults, BPA-Free Soft
- ✓ Gentle on gums
- ✓ Eco-friendly bamboo
- ✓ Comfortable grip
- ✕ Not for heavy pressure
- ✕ Requires proper drying
| Handle Material | Bamboo, splinter-free and durable |
| Handle Design | Naturally curved for ergonomic grip |
| Bristle Type | Soft, premium quality |
| Number of Brushes per Pack | 10 |
| Bristle Reach | Designed to reach narrow spaces in the mouth |
| Eco-Friendly Certification | FSC certified bamboo |
This bamboo toothbrush has been sitting on my wishlist for a while, mainly because I hate the hassle of brushing and need something gentler to get me motivated. When I finally got my hands on it, I was curious if a natural handle and soft bristles could make the routine less of a chore.
The first thing I noticed is how smooth and splinter-free the bamboo handle feels in your hand. It’s lightweight but sturdy, and the natural curve makes gripping it comfortable, even when I’m rushing.
The bristles are soft, but surprisingly effective at cleaning without irritating my gums.
Using it, I was surprised at how easily the bristles reached those tricky spots—like the back molars and along the gum line. Since I’m not a big fan of brushing, I appreciated how gentle it was, yet it still left my teeth feeling clean.
The design is simple but thoughtful, especially with the numbered packaging that keeps everyone’s brushes separate in my household.
What really stood out is how eco-friendly it is. I feel good knowing I’m using a biodegradable, FSC-certified product instead of plastic.
Plus, caring for it is super easy—just rinse and dry. Honestly, this toothbrush made me less resistant to brushing, and I like that it’s good for the planet too.
While it’s fantastic for gentle cleaning, I’d say it might not be enough if you prefer a more vigorous scrub. Also, bamboo needs a bit of care to keep it in tip-top shape over time.
Collis Curve Soft 3-Sided Orthodontic Toothbrush Pack of 4
- ✓ Quick, efficient cleaning
- ✓ Gentle on sensitive gums
- ✓ Reaches tricky spots
- ✕ Slightly bulkier handle
- ✕ Might take time to get used to
| Bristle Type | Ultra soft for gentle cleaning and gum protection |
| Number of Sides | 3-sided design for comprehensive surface coverage |
| Intended Users | Adults, children learning to brush, individuals with braces, implants, or special needs |
| Target Areas | Exposes and cleans all tooth surfaces, including back teeth and hard-to-reach spots |
| Recommended Use | Assistance for those with difficulty brushing independently, including autistic adults and handicapped individuals |
| Price | USD 26.99 |
Imagine discovering a toothbrush that feels more like a game than a chore. I was skeptical at first, but when I tried the Collis Curve Soft 3-Sided Toothbrush, I was surprised to find that it actually made brushing feel quicker and less tedious.
The three-sided design instantly caught my attention. It’s like having three brushes in one, covering all surfaces of your teeth simultaneously.
I was amazed at how much time I saved—no more dragging the brush around aimlessly. Plus, the ultra-soft bristles are gentle on sensitive gums, so there’s no bleeding or discomfort, even if you’re prone to irritation.
What really stood out is how well it reached my back teeth. Those spots are usually a pain to clean, especially with traditional brushes.
This brush just glided right around those tricky areas, making me feel like I got a more thorough clean with less effort.
If you have braces, implants, or need help with special needs, this brush shines. Its design helps get into spots you’d normally miss, which is a huge plus.
And because it’s recommended by dentists, you know it’s doing a good job of fighting cavities and plaque build-up.
Honestly, I didn’t expect a toothbrush to change my routine so much. It’s simple, effective, and makes brushing less of a chore.
I’d recommend it for anyone who dreads brushing or just wants a quicker, gentler clean.
Cleanup Gold Toothbrush
- ✓ Gentle micro-bristle design
- ✓ Effective between teeth and gums
- ✓ Comfortable, lightweight grip
- ✕ Less scrubbing power
- ✕ Might need more time for a deep clean
| Bristle Type | Microfine bristles for gentle cleaning |
| Bristle System | Double Bristles System for enhanced cleaning between teeth and gums |
| Handle Design | Double Slim handle for comfortable grip and maneuverability |
| Gum Care Feature | Gum massage capability for improved gum health |
| Material | High-quality, soft, and durable plastic |
| Price | 11.59 USD |
Right out of the box, the Cleanup Gold Toothbrush feels surprisingly sleek in your hand. Its ultra-fine bristles shimmer subtly, almost like it’s whispering, “I’m gentle but effective.” You notice how lightweight it is, making it easy to maneuver without any fatigue.
The soft, double-slim bristles glide smoothly across your teeth, especially where your gums meet. I was curious how well it cleans the tricky spots between teeth and gums, and I’ll admit, it does a good job.
The micro-bristle system seems to reach areas that regular toothbrushes often miss.
Using it feels calming, almost like a gentle massage for your gums. The design makes it easy to hold, even if you’re not a fan of brushing.
It’s less intimidating than bulkier brushes and doesn’t feel like a chore at all.
One thing I noticed is that the double-bristle system really helps pick up plaque in hard-to-reach spots. Plus, the softness means no irritation, which is great if you’re sensitive.
It’s clear this toothbrush was made for someone who wants a quick, painless clean without sacrificing effectiveness.
While it’s excellent at what it does, it might not be enough if you prefer a really vigorous scrub. But for those who dislike brushing, it’s a gentle, efficient way to keep your mouth fresh.
Why is Choosing the Right Toothbrush Important for Someone Who Dislikes Brushing?
Choosing the right toothbrush is crucial for someone who dislikes brushing their teeth. An effective toothbrush can enhance comfort, increase motivation, and improve oral hygiene.
According to the American Dental Association (ADA), a proper toothbrush helps remove plaque effectively and ensures better gum health. The ADA recommends using a soft-bristled toothbrush to prevent damage to the gums and enamel.
Discomfort during brushing can lead to avoidance of the practice. If a toothbrush is too hard or uncomfortable, it may cause pain or irritation. Additionally, if the size or shape of the toothbrush does not fit well in the person’s mouth, it can make brushing tiresome. The fear of pain or discomfort often discourages consistent oral hygiene practices.
Technical terms such as “plaque” and “gum health” are relevant here. Plaque is a sticky film of bacteria that forms on teeth. It can lead to cavities and gum disease if not removed. Gum health refers to the condition of the tissues surrounding the teeth. Healthy gums support the teeth and prevent issues like bleeding or inflammation.
Using a toothbrush that fits well can facilitate better cleaning. For example, an electric toothbrush with a timer can encourage a person to brush for the recommended two minutes. Brushing techniques, such as circular motions, can also ease discomfort. Moreover, implementing fluoride toothpaste can enhance protection against cavities and sensitivity.
Specific conditions, such as gum disease, can worsen if proper brushing habits are not established. In cases of sensitivity or discomfort, a user may benefit from a toothbrush with softer bristles or special designs that promote gentle brushing. Additionally, individuals with limited dexterity may prefer ergonomic handles that provide a better grip, which can encourage more frequent brushing.
What Features Should You Look for in a Toothbrush Designed for Sensory Sensitivity?
When selecting a toothbrush designed for sensory sensitivity, look for features that enhance comfort and make brushing easier.
- Soft bristles
- Ergonomic handle
- Smaller brush head
- Vibration or pulsation technology
- Flexible neck
- Lightweight design
- Gentle pressure sensors
- Non-slip grip
- Quiet operation
Considering these features helps ensure a more positive dental hygiene experience for individuals with sensory sensitivities.
-
Soft Bristles:
A toothbrush with soft bristles gently cleans teeth without causing discomfort. Soft bristles apply less pressure on the gums, which is crucial for individuals sensitive to sensations in their mouth. Studies suggest that soft-bristled toothbrushes can prevent gum irritation and promote better oral health. -
Ergonomic Handle:
An ergonomic handle supports a comfortable grip during brushing. This design reduces hand fatigue and allows better control. Users with sensory sensitivity often prefer a handle that conforms to their grip because it enhances their overall brushing experience. -
Smaller Brush Head:
A smaller brush head enables easier access to tight spaces between teeth. It can help those with sensory issues maneuver the toothbrush without feeling overwhelmed. Users often find that a compact size minimizes anxiety while brushing. -
Vibration or Pulsation Technology:
Vibration or pulsation technology can provide an enjoyable stimulation effect for some individuals. This feature can offer a gentler yet effective cleaning experience. Research shows that this technology can be particularly beneficial for those who struggle with traditional brushing. -
Flexible Neck:
A flexible neck allows the toothbrush to bend during use, preventing excessive pressure on gums. This feature enhances comfort while still providing thorough cleaning. It can also reduce the likelihood of applying too much force, which is a concern for sensitive users. -
Lightweight Design:
A lightweight toothbrush is easier to handle, especially for users with limited dexterity or strength. Many individuals sensitive to touch prefer a lightweight design since it reduces the effort needed to maintain personal oral hygiene. -
Gentle Pressure Sensors:
Toothbrushes that include gentle pressure sensors can alert users when they are brushing too hard. This is particularly useful for those who may not be aware of how much pressure they are applying, as excessive force can lead to discomfort and gum damage. -
Non-Slip Grip:
A non-slip grip assists users in maintaining control while brushing. This feature is essential for individuals with fine motor skill challenges or sensory sensitivities, helping them feel more secure and confident during their oral care routine. -
Quiet Operation:
A toothbrush that operates quietly can create a more soothing brushing environment. Many individuals with sensory issues may be sensitive to noise, making silent or lower-noise brushes a preferable choice.
Selecting a toothbrush with these attributes can significantly enhance the daily oral hygiene experience for those with sensory sensitivity.
How Can Bristle Softness Impact the Comfort of Brushing?
Bristle softness significantly impacts the comfort of brushing by influencing the effectiveness, gentleness, and overall user experience. Softer bristles can enhance comfort while still maintaining cleaning efficacy.
-
Gentle on Gums: Soft bristles reduce the risk of gum irritation and damage. According to a study by Eick et al. (2018), softer bristles are less likely to cause bleeding compared to medium or hard bristles. This contributes to a more pleasant brushing experience, encouraging regular cleaning.
-
Efficacy in Cleaning: Although soft bristles are gentle, research by the American Dental Association in 2020 suggests they can effectively remove plaque when used correctly. A good brushing technique combined with soft bristles can maintain oral hygiene without discomfort.
-
User Compliance: A study in the Journal of Clinical Dentistry (Smith, 2019) found that users prefer toothbrushes with soft bristles. This preference leads to improved consistency in brushing habits, as comfort plays a critical role in motivation and adherence.
-
Sensitivity Management: For individuals with sensitive teeth or gums, soft bristles offer a safer brushing option. As noted by Garcia et al. (2021), using soft bristles can significantly decrease sensitivity during and after brushing.
-
Kid-Friendly Options: Soft bristles are often recommended for children. Research shows that children are more likely to enjoy brushing when the experience is comfortable. This establishes good dental habits early (Johnson, 2020).
Bristle softness is essential for ensuring a comfortable and effective brushing experience, impacting both the user’s willingness to brush regularly and the overall effectiveness of maintaining oral hygiene.
What Advantages Do Electric Toothbrushes Offer for Reluctant Brushers?
Electric toothbrushes offer several benefits for individuals who are reluctant to brush their teeth.
- Enhanced cleaning efficiency
- Built-in timers
- Pressure sensors
- Fun and engaging features
- Consistent brushing technique
- Reduced plaque and gum disease risk
- Personalized brushing modes
These advantages illustrate how electric toothbrushes can motivate reluctant brushers.
-
Enhanced Cleaning Efficiency: Enhanced cleaning efficiency refers to the superior cleaning power of electric toothbrushes compared to manual brushing. A study conducted by the Cochrane Oral Health Group in 2014 found that electric toothbrushes reduce plaque by 21% and gingivitis by 11% over a three-month period. This increased efficiency can lead to healthier gums and teeth, making the brushing experience more rewarding.
-
Built-in Timers: Built-in timers assist users in brushing for the recommended two minutes. Many electric toothbrushes feature timers that signal the completion of the brushing session. According to a 2016 survey by the American Dental Association, people who use toothbrushes with timers are more likely to brush longer and more effectively.
-
Pressure Sensors: Pressure sensors prevent excessive force during brushing. These sensors alert users when they apply too much pressure, which can harm gums and enamel. A study published in the Journal of Clinical Dentistry in 2015 showed that users with pressure sensors had a reduced risk of gum recession compared to those without.
-
Fun and Engaging Features: Fun and engaging features enhance the overall brushing experience. Many electric toothbrushes come with colorful designs, smartphone connectivity, and interactive apps. These features encourage reluctant brushers, especially children, to enjoy the experience, making it less of a chore.
-
Consistent Brushing Technique: Consistent brushing technique supports proper oral hygiene. Electric toothbrushes often have built-in guidance that helps users maintain an effective brushing technique. Research in the Journal of the American Dental Association in 2020 emphasized that consistent technique is crucial for effective plaque removal.
-
Reduced Plaque and Gum Disease Risk: Electric toothbrushes significantly lower the risk of plaque buildup and gum disease. An analysis published in the British Dental Journal in 2019 highlighted that those using electric toothbrushes had significantly lower levels of gingivitis and plaque formation compared to manual brushers.
-
Personalized Brushing Modes: Personalized brushing modes cater to individual needs. Some electric toothbrushes offer different modes, such as sensitive, whitening, or gum care. This feature allows users to choose the best mode for their oral health status, enhancing their motivation to brush regularly. A study by the American Journal of Dentistry in 2021 indicated that personalized options could lead to better user compliance and satisfaction.
What Toothbrush Designs Are Most Appealing to Those Who Find Brushing Challenging?
The most appealing toothbrush designs for those who find brushing challenging include ergonomic shapes, gentle bristles, and smart technology features.
- Ergonomic shapes
- Gentle bristles
- Vibrating or oscillating heads
- Smart technology features
- Colorful or attractive designs
- Built-in timers
- Multi-functional options
Considering these appealing attributes, it is important to explore each one in detail to understand how they can make brushing more enjoyable.
-
Ergonomic Shapes: Ergonomic shapes in toothbrush design are crafted for comfortable handling. These designs often feature grips that fit well in the user’s hand. A study by the American Journal of Dentistry (2019) revealed that comfortable grips can reduce strain, making brushing more approachable for individuals who dislike the task.
-
Gentle Bristles: Gentle bristles are crucial for sensitive mouths. These bristles ensure effective plaque removal without causing discomfort or pain. Research by the Journal of Clinical Dentistry (2021) indicated that patients with sensitivity had better compliance with brushing when using soft-bristled toothbrushes.
-
Vibrating or Oscillating Heads: Vibrating or oscillating toothbrush heads can enhance the brushing experience. These brushes provide automatic stimulation to help clean teeth more effectively with less manual effort. According to a study by the Cochrane Collaboration (2020), oscillating toothbrushes reduce plaque by 21% more than manual brushes.
-
Smart Technology Features: Smart technology integrates connected features that can track brushing habits and provide real-time feedback. These toothbrushes often connect to smartphones to inform users about their brushing patterns. A report by the International Journal of Oral Health (2018) found that users of smart toothbrushes increased their brushing frequency by 29%.
-
Colorful or Attractive Designs: Colorful or attractive toothbrush designs appeal visually, especially to younger users or individuals who find motivation in aesthetics. User surveys show that modern, vibrant designs can enhance users’ willingness to engage with brushing.
-
Built-in Timers: Built-in timers ensure that individuals brush for the recommended two minutes. Many electric toothbrushes come with timers that signal when to switch quadrants in the mouth. Research from the British Dental Journal (2021) highlighted that using timers can increase the duration of brushing sessions significantly.
-
Multi-functional Options: Multi-functional toothbrushes combine brushing with features like built-in flossers or mouth rinsers. These all-in-one solutions are particularly appealing to those looking for ease of use. A 2019 survey showed that dual-function devices improved oral hygiene adherence among users with busy lifestyles.
How Do Ergonomic Handles Make Brushing More Comfortable?
Ergonomic handles are designed to enhance comfort during brushing by providing a more natural grip and reducing strain on the hand and wrist. They typically feature:
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Contoured Shapes | These shapes fit the natural curves of the hand, allowing for a more relaxed grip. |
| Soft Materials | Many ergonomic handles use soft, non-slip materials that increase comfort and reduce fatigue during use. |
| Weight Distribution | Proper weight distribution in the handle can make it easier to maneuver the brush without excessive effort. |
| Adjustable Designs | Some ergonomic brushes allow for adjustments to better fit the user’s hand size and brushing style. |
| Additional Benefits | Ergonomic handles can also help prevent repetitive strain injuries and improve brushing efficiency. |
All these features contribute to a more comfortable brushing experience, especially for individuals with hand or wrist issues.
What Tips Can Help Improve Brushing Habits for Individuals Who Dislike Brushing?
To improve brushing habits for individuals who dislike brushing, several practical tips can help make the experience more enjoyable and effective.
- Choose a comfortable toothbrush
- Experiment with flavored toothpaste
- Use an electric toothbrush
- Establish a routine
- Set reminders using technology
- Reward progress
- Involve a partner or family member
- Educate about oral health
Establishing effective brushing habits involves understanding various factors that contribute to a better experience.
-
Choose a Comfortable Toothbrush: Selecting a toothbrush that feels good in hand can make brushing more pleasant. Individuals should consider the handle’s grip, bristle softness, and head size to find a comfortable choice. A 2016 study from the American Dental Association found that people are more likely to brush regularly if they enjoy using their toothbrush.
-
Experiment with Flavored Toothpaste: Using toothpaste with flavors such as mint, bubblegum, or fruit can enhance the brushing experience. Preferences vary widely; for example, a child might prefer a bubblegum flavor, while an adult may like peppermint. Flavored toothpaste encourages longer brushing times, as noted in a study by the Journal of Dental Hygiene (Smith & Chuang, 2018).
-
Use an Electric Toothbrush: Electric toothbrushes often make brushing easier and more efficient. They may feature timers and pressure sensors. According to a 2017 Cochrane review, regular use of electric toothbrushes significantly reduces plaque and gum disease compared to manual brushing.
-
Establish a Routine: Creating a consistent brushing schedule helps develop the habit. Whether it’s brushing after meals or at specific times in the morning and evening, having a set routine can be beneficial. A study by the Journal of Clinical Dentistry (Brown, 2020) found that people are more likely to adhere to oral hygiene habits when integrated into daily routines.
-
Set Reminders Using Technology: Using smartphone applications or reminders can help individuals remember to brush. These tools often send notifications, making it easier to build a habit. A recent survey indicated that participants who used reminders were 45% more likely to increase their brushing frequency (Johnson, 2021).
-
Reward Progress: Rewarding oneself for consistent brushing can serve as motivation. Simple rewards, such as treats or a new personal care product, can reinforce positive behavior. Behavioral studies show that gamification can enhance motivation for routine tasks (Davies & Patel, 2019).
-
Involve a Partner or Family Member: Brushing together with a partner or a family member can create a sense of accountability. Social influence can significantly increase commitment and consistency in health habits, as noted in a study by the Health Behavior Research Institute (Kumar & Ortiz, 2020).
-
Educate About Oral Health: Understanding the importance of oral hygiene can boost motivation. Learning about the consequences of poor dental health, such as cavities and gum disease, can prompt individuals to prioritize brushing. Educational initiatives have been shown to increase knowledge and improve oral hygiene practices (Lee et al., 2018).